Export bans and stocking limits: are they working? | Knowledge


A coverage transient argued for a rational commerce coverage to comprise meals inflation which takes under consideration each customers and producers.
| Photograph Credit score: TRAVELLINGLIGHT

A coverage transient issued by the Indian Council for Analysis on Worldwide Financial Relations mentioned that the current steps taken by the federal government to curb inflation, reminiscent of wheat and rice export bans and growing export duties, had been “knee-jerk approaches relatively than a well-thought-out technique”. It argued for a rational commerce coverage to comprise meals inflation which takes under consideration each customers and producers.

In August 2023, retail inflation accelerated to six.83%, which is greater than the ceiling of 6%. As meals and drinks carry a 57% weightage in India’s retail inflation calculation, and meals inflation was 9.94%, speedy acceleration in that phase had a extreme impression on retail inflation (Chart 1).

Chart 1 | The chart reveals the development of retail inflation (darkish blue) and meals inflation (gentle blue) over time.

Chart seems incomplete? Click on to take away AMP mode.

Thus far, the Indian authorities has applied a sequence of actions geared toward controlling meals inflation reminiscent of prohibiting the export of wheat in Could 2022 and halting the export of damaged rice in September 2022. Moreover, in June 2023, the federal government imposed stocking limits on wheat merchants and millers. In July 2023, an export ban was positioned on non-basmati white rice, adopted by a 20% export responsibility on parboiled rice. In August 2023, a Minimal Export Worth of $1,200 per tonne was set for basmati rice, together with a 40% export responsibility on onions.

Chart 2 | The chart reveals the chronology of commerce and home inventory coverage measures to tame the inflation of rice and wheat. 

Attributable to heatwaves, the manufacturing of wheat has suffered within the final two years. Wheat procurement by the federal government has additionally been low within the final two cycles. Wheat inflation was 9.22% in August. All this prompted the federal government to ban wheat exports in Could 2022, argues the transient. “However this sudden ban on wheat exports, as an alternative of bringing wheat inflation down, led to larger uncertainty out there and wheat inflation surged to 15.7 per cent in August 2022, when GOI additionally banned exports of wheat flour (atta) merchandise,” says the coverage transient. Simply earlier than the harvest season, wheat inflation accelerated to 25.4% in February 2023. Following this, the federal government off-loaded wheat underneath the Open Market Gross sales Scheme at less expensive costs and introduced wheat stocking limits, in response to the coverage transient. Whereas these measures did deliver down inflation, the report argues that the implications of such measures on farmers who bore the brunt should be taken under consideration.

Click on to subscribe to our Knowledge e-newsletter

Chart 3 | The chart reveals tendencies in cereal exports in India. 

Knowledge from the report reveals that non-basmati exports elevated from 1.38 MMT in FY20 to six.40 MMT in FY23, by 363%. The report argues that within the fiscal yr 2023, the per-tonne export worth for non-basmati rice stood at $344, falling under India’s Minimal Help Worth (MSP) for rice. This means that millers could also be sourcing rice straight from farmers or that there could possibly be a rise in rice provide as a consequence of potential distribution leakages from the expanded PMGKAY free rice programme. 

Chart 4 | The chart reveals the offtake of rice and wheat underneath the Nationwide Meals Safety Act and PMGKY from the central pool. 

Chart 3 and Chart 4 underscore the expansion in rice and wheat offtake throughout the final three years, in addition to the numerous rise in grain exports from India over the identical time interval.

In July 2023, when rice inflation was 13%, the federal government banned the export of non-basmati rice. But, inflation remained at 12.5%. Reasonably than imposing export responsibility and regularly growing its impression, the federal government referred to as for a ban which created panic among the many African and Indian diaspora within the U.S., in response to the report.

Supply: A report referred to as “Tackling meals inflation: Is limiting exports and imposing stocking limits the optimum coverage?” revealed by the Indian Council for Analysis on Worldwide Financial Relations

Additionally learn | Knowledge | Warmth wave in Punjab might curtail India’s wheat exports

Hearken to our podcast |A dialogue on Madras HC judgment: Spouse can declare a share in husband’s property | Knowledge Level podcast

supply hyperlink