Midtown has highest retail vacancy rate in NYC: report


Midtown Manhattan is struggling worse than some other neighborhood within the metropolis relating to storefront retail areas, in keeping with a brand new actual property trade report.

Almost 30 p.c of storefronts in New York’s prime enterprise district are empty as a “devastating” lack of workplace employees means there’s not sufficient prospects to maintain retailers up-and-running, in keeping with the Actual Property Board of New York.

These vacancies far outpace empty storefronts in additional residential neighborhoods the place there’s nonetheless a important mass of individuals retailers depend on.

In Midtown, in keeping with the REBNY report, solely about 25 p.c to 30 p.c of the traditional variety of employees are coming into the workplace — that means about 60,000 folks on the streets for lunches, haircuts, procuring or shoeshines. That compares to 180,000 workplace employees within the space earlier than the pandemic lockdowns.

Such a dearth of individuals has led to the spike in storefront vacancies — even on key corners and on ritzy Madison Avenue, in keeping with the REBNY report. Some complete blocks are stuffed with empty storefronts.

Chart from REBNY that shows high storefront vacancy rates
Statistics compiled by the Actual Property Board of New York as of this summer time present excessive storefront emptiness charges in neighborhoods which might be depending on workplace employees. Residential neighborhoods have fared higher.

The areas close to Grand Central Terminal and within the Midtown East neighborhood have storefront vacancies of 29.9 p.c, in keeping with the report. In 2018, storefronts round Grand Central have been solely 10.9 p.c vacant; Midtown East reported a 15.three p.c emptiness on the time.

These figures jibe with different statistics that present small companies and retailers, together with eating places and bars, have been among the many hardest-hit within the Large Apple, as The Publish has reported.

“REBNY’s findings affirm the crippling impact that the pandemic has had – and continues to have – on the retail sector in Midtown Manhattan,” Fred Cerullo, president and CEO of the Grand Central Partnership, mentioned in an announcement. “For these companies to thrive, they want the type of foot visitors generated by vacationers and workplace employees.” 

Labor Day was purported to kick off the return to places of work, however the Delta variant pushed again many corporations’ plans to deliver again workers.

A block of stores that are empty.
Midtown has the next proportion of complete blocks which have vacant storefronts.
Bloomberg through Getty Photos

About two-thirds of corporations delayed their returns to the workplace to way back to early 2022, in keeping with a Gartner research in August, whereas a current report from The Partnership for New York discovered that metropolis employers had anticipated solely 41 p.c of workplace employees to have returned by Sept. 30 — down from a earlier estimate of 60 p.c. 

The retail sector in some residential neighborhoods within the outer boroughs, in the meantime, have fared a lot better than these in Manhattan, the report mentioned. The retail emptiness price in Greenpoint and Prospect Heights in Brooklyn was 14.6 p.c; it was 14 p.c in Astoria and Sunnyside in Queens.

However retail corridors that rely upon workplace commuters have lagged behind these in residential neighborhoods. Subway ridership as of September has has risen to solely 50 p.c of pre-pandemic ranges, the report notes. And Manhattan accounts for almost half of the town’s jobs within the retail sector.

A Gap store that closed for good.
Many large chain retailers have contributed to the excessive retail emptiness price in Manhattan.
Bloomberg through Getty Photos

All of these companies are large enterprise for New York: The retail sector in 2019 offered 344,600 jobs and contributed $55 billion in taxable gross sales to the town’s financial system, in keeping with the report.

To counter the detrimental developments, REBNY, which represents the town’s largest actual property pursuits, advisable the town and state deal with aggressive vaccination insurance policies and encourage employers to deliver employees again to the workplace.

“New York Metropolis continues to be reeling,” the report mentioned. “Restoring the town’s financial system is not going to be full with out the retail sector.”

An empty corner retail space.
The world round Grand Central Terminal and Midtown East has among the many most nook retail vacancies.
Getty Photos